‘A Place of Meadows and Tall Trees’ Reviews

A Place of Meadows and Tall Trees by Clare Dudman.

An intensely moving novel based on stories about the trails and triumphs of nineteenth-century Welsh immigrants attempting to set up a Welsh-speaking colony in Patagonia. The protagonist Silas James is a character you instantly connect with, and the in-depth descriptions make you feel as though you are sitting in the Patagonian desert. A word of caution: this storry is filled with tragedy, so have your tissues at the ready.

Buzz Magazine

I was completely carried away and overwhelmed..(.).This narrative about the Welsh colonists of Patagonia would be a ripping yarn, as they say, in the hands of any competent writer. It has danger, dashed dreams, fears, jealousies, romance — everything you could want in a novel. But in the hands of the calibre of Dudman, this has become much, much more.

Sue Guiney Writing Life Blog

Although the book is a novel it really does capture the historical contact beautifully – you can feel the hardship of reaching place, only to discover that the promised land meadows and tall trees are actually scrubland and bare earth. The author is always wonderful at giving us a feel of what it’s like to live in a different environment, and I’ve never seen it done better. Lyrical and informative in equal parts, this is a novel that a non-fiction reader can appreciate for its descriptive content while still giving flight to the imagination and good development of characters that the reader cares about. Recommended.

Brian Clegg, Now Appearing Blog

A Place of Meadows and Tall Trees is a lovely novel, which I highly recommend for a rich and rewarding experience.

Anne Sydenham, Cat Politics Blog

Full of finely drawn characters…. Clare Dudman pulls the reader into their lives until the hardship and misery they experience is practically palpable. A work of fiction that is all her own…. Her extensive research gives the novel an air of urgency and realism that makes it a gripping read.

Carola Huttmann, Bookmunch

This is a good book…an engrossing book. I feel the book’s strength lies in its portrayal of real people. It focuses on identity, national identity on the surface, but once you start to dig a little deeper there are other identities under the microscope here and the old Indian provides an excellent sounding board, not that he doesn’t have his own identity issues which he deals with in his own way. I grew rather fond of old Yeluc and would have liked more of him.


You can read a detailed review of this title on Jim Murdoch’s blog: http://jim-murdoch.blogspot.com/2010/06/place-of-meadows-and-tall-trees….

This powerful work of fiction tells like no historical account possibly could of the trials faced by the mostly desperate Welsh who sailed for Patagonia to found a new Wales, Y Wladfa – and the native Americans whose lives also changed forever. Fiction it may be, but Dudman has, in her own words, “taken the bare bones of the lives of various people that were part of that first, courageous settlement and invented their flesh”. Before that, she travelled across Patagonia in a bus, talked to descendents of the first settlers and took intensive courses in Welsh and shamanism. Her inventions feature fine character portrayals, like the elegant, talkative, trilingual Edwyn Lloyd, the expedition leader, based loosely on Lewis Jones, the Caernarfon printer whose pioneering work on the railway was recognised when the town at the railhead was named Trelew in his honour. The railway came years after the expedition fictionalised here. The year is 1865 and the novel centres on settler Silas James, who travels with his heavily pregnant wife Megan and their children after being evicted from their tenant farm in Wales. Fiction and imagination are all we have to understand what it must have been like for them to travel in hope towards a dream world, lose a son on a long hard voyage and arrive to find a cold barren windswept desert. Dreams are strange too, and take unexpected directions. Award-winning novelist Dudman has written another powerful contender for honours with this atmospheric, lyrical page-turner, enriched by the character Yeluc, the shaman son of an Indian chief. His view of the settlers is given added intensity by use of the first person singular. This story of the settlers’ struggle to survive is uncompromising, but laced with hope.

Steve Dube, The Western Mail, 5th June 2010


One thought on “‘A Place of Meadows and Tall Trees’ Reviews

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.